00:00:01 Jonathan Eaton Hey everybody, my name is Jonathan Eaton. I am the CEO of Synergy Information Solutions, and we’ve been working with Tribes for 22 years. Before that, I was a software engineer at a California Tribe, and I earned something called the CISSP at that time. Which stands for Certified Information Systems Security Professional, which means I’m kind of an IT security geek too. Today, I’m a Harvard Business School alumnus. Did some training at MIT on AI. We’ve been consulting on AI over the last two years, doing AI readiness assessments, etc. I think it’s a really important topic for the room. Those of you awake Who uses something like ChatGPT? Who doesn’t use ChatGPT? I’m curious about that. No ChatGPT, or you know, Gemini, Claude, whatever flavor. So who doesn’t use any of those things? So we have one hand. Who uses one of these every single day?
00:01:10 Patrick Tinklenberg Every day. About half the room.
00:01:14 Jonathan Eaton So I think if I had asked that question two years ago, I would have gotten a different response. Obviously, this AI thing is pretty important. How are you using it? Would you have imagined using something like this and chatting with it before? This technology is becoming very important, and the adoption is becoming very important. So AI is already integrated into Tribal enterprises currently. And it’s really on two different tracks. There’s sanctioned and unsanctioned AI. People who should be using it are using it.
00:01:52 Patrick Tinklenberg People are using it.
00:01:54 Jonathan Eaton Probably, and studies show this, quite a lot of people are using it on your data who haven’t been approved to use it on your data. So we definitely want to talk, dig into that. And with that, we have a UNLV study that’s recent. It gave land-based casinos a score of 39 out of 100 for AI maturity. So 39 out of 100. So we have a lot of AI that’s already happening. Sanctioned or not And the maturity is clearly low. So when I turn it over to my panel here, let’s do a one-minute introduction about AI in the world and what I just said. We’ll start with Patrick.
00:02:48 Patrick Tinklenberg Good morning, everybody. My name is Patrick Tinklenberg. I’m the vice president of IT at Sycuan Casino Resort in wonderful, sunny San Diego. I’ve been there about 13 years. Before that, I was with the Barona Band of Mission Indians as the head of IT. For the Tribal government and the Barona Gaming Commission. So I’ve been working for Tribes and Tribal gaming for almost twenty years now, which seems like forever. Just a quick little bit of background with us. Obviously, we’re looking very closely at AI within our organization. It’s something I think. Everybody wants to do it, but not everybody is quite ready for it yet. We’re in this phase where we’re looking at all the different ways we use it, but we’re also looking at how ready we are for this. The UNLV study was amazing because it looked closely at what people have done to get ready for AI. I think everybody is jumping in, and parts of the organization are much more capable of adopting AI. And other parts are just not there yet.
00:04:07 Patrick Tinklenberg Looking holistically at the organization because you can’t deploy AI in pockets. It really spreads quickly, and so you have to look organization wide and understand how you are ready. Because data is pervasive across your organization. It lives everywhere. And if you don’t know where those boundaries are and what data is important and what data should be protected, then AI can just vacuum it all up. And so you have to be ready. Have to look really closely, and that’s why we’re doing a lot of that right now. And we’re going to get into that As we talk more, that’s going to be a big theme, and what people are really looking for as they get closer to making big investments in AI going forward.
00:04:55 Jonathan Eaton So speaking of UNLV
00:04:58 Danielle Finn Go Rebels. Good day, everybody. My name is Danielle Finn, and I’m the director of the Indian Nations Gaming and Governance Program, which was started at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas School of Law, thanks to a very generous gift from the Yuhaaviatam of San Manuel Nation in 2020. We are a new Indian law program and really focus on governance, which is really all aspects of what Tribal Nations are about, as well as Tribal gaming. I’m coming at this from a couple of different hats. Just because I have this job as a director and a professor at the law school, but I’m also a sitting judge and I’ve been on the bench for eight years for the Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe. So as an associate judge, I’ve been implementing AI into how I’m drafting orders or hearing cases. But I also sit on multiple boards, and in my roles as a board member or a director, I’m also using AI. And I can tell you, as a professor, we’re using AI in the law school. Do you want me to dive a little deeper? AI is everywhere in the world right now.
00:06:05 Jonathan Eaton AI is everywhere. You’ll notice we’re missing one of our panelists. He had a really important Tribal matter to deal with, so he’s not here. He represents Tribal government. It sounds like both of you are very well-rounded in Tribal government too, so we can have some good conversations on that side. This is the shift. Twenty-four months ago, AI in Tribal operations was a pilot. Today, it’s definitely embedded, sanctioned or not. Shadow AI is a term that’s used out there. I’m not sure if you’ve heard it, but it means AI that’s being used without authorization. Somebody goes home. Your general manager might put an email into their personal ChatGPT account. Probably not cool, but it is definitely happening. Statistically, we see a lot of that. So, a question for Patrick: Where is AI already operating in your organization, sanctioned or not? I know that’s a lot of questions.
00:07:07 Patrick Tinklenberg So I think people don’t quite understand all of the different areas where AI can creep in. I think one of the more interesting things was a couple of years ago when I was sitting with our marketing team. Talking to our creative services department about some of the tools that they were using And AI was already really well established within all of the Adobe tools that they were using. Like we didn’t even we didn’t even know. We had from a technology standpoint, we didn’t even know that AI was already embedded in just about everything Adobe had out a year and a half, two years ago. And we’re like, well I guess you know the door is open. We’re going to figure out how to manage this and what we’re going to do. And it was, and once we realized that, and started looking Once we realized that, we started looking. Our third parties had so many third-party vendors working with them that were also using AI on data given to them.
00:08:04 Patrick Tinklenberg And we didn’t vet any of that. We didn’t look at those third parties and talk to them about what they were doing with AI, what they were doing with our data. It made us realize that now we had to have some language in our agreements with our third parties. How are they going to start using that data? What AI platforms are they allowed to use? Because essentially, if they’re using it, we’re using it, and so we had to pay attention to that as well. And then, obviously, we had other parts of our organization, whether it was HR or accounting or our casino hosts, who were using it to craft emails. We had to go back through and really talk with every department about what they were doing, how they were using this, why they were using this, and whether they had received any training at all. Most of them hadn’t.
00:08:49 Jonathan Eaton So quick follow up question for you then. What kinds of sanctioned AI solutions have been working well for Sycuan?
00:08:57 Patrick Tinklenberg So once we understood exactly what people were already doing Once we understood exactly what people were already doing, we started talking to them about scaling down the tools that were available. Instead of people having Claude, ChatGPT, and different tools across the board, we tried to bring it down to one set of tools and then say, ‘Here’s the training you’ve got.’ We use Claude for code development. We let our folks in accounting use Claude for some automation. And then we have some tools that we built within the Microsoft Azure AI platform. That’s a sanctioned AI platform that we use for policy management as well as some stuff that we do with our enterprise data warehouse. It’s been fairly limited, and we’re trying to do it intentionally. We’re trying to really look at the use cases and say, here’s a place where we can use it. If we’re going to train you on how to use it, we’re going to train you on what’s acceptable. We’re going to train you on being cognizant of what the results are and really making sure that you’re testing that and not just accepting what comes out of these AI.
00:10:07 Jonathan Eaton There was something mentioned in the keynote about training budgets being so important for any project. The development of the people has to be ubiquitous. For AI, you have to think that’s incredibly important.
00:10:25 Patrick Tinklenberg Early on, it was funny. We had people who were putting personal information about our players into platforms so that they could write an email or send a mass notification out to a bunch of people. They were putting personal information into these to craft these emails, and they didn’t understand that once that information was out there, it was out there. It was then public information, and they just didn’t understand that. And so that gets to the training and education piece. You really have to let people know Hey, once this information is out, if it’s not our AI and it’s not built in a sandbox that we built for you, then it’s out there. It may become public, and we can’t have that kind of proprietary, confidential information getting out into the public.
00:11:12 Jonathan Eaton Danielle, a question for you on that train of thought: What risks have you identified around AI accessing or misusing cultural or Tribal heritage information?
00:11:24 Danielle Finn AI handles volume and retrieval. What you’re putting into it is what it’s going to keep and save. In schools right now, we tell them if you don’t want AI to know something, don’t feed it. Don’t feed what you don’t want to know or to keep. And that goes for our culture and our things that we want to protect. Don’t feed it into AI because then AI won’t know about it, or we can keep it sacred for ourselves.
00:11:52 Jonathan Eaton Awesome. So on that level, we have the CARE Principles, actually. We have the CARE Principles. These go back to 2019. Who is following the CARE Principles? They show up out there. I’m always curious who is actually following them or who knows what the CARE Principles are. Nobody. That’s very interesting. So, in August 2025, the Cherokee Nation enacted its first formal Tribal AI policy. It’s along the lines of what we were talking about. Danielle, sorry. So who decides and on what authority does that decision rest? Typically, I think.
00:12:42 Danielle Finn Every tribe can determine for themselves. This is our sovereignty. You get to decide whether or not you would like to implement AI and any or all of your institutions, or ban it outright. Every tribe is taking a different approach. Every establishment is taking a different approach. I can tell you just from our different law schools across the country UNLV’s law school is embracing AI, and we are actually mandating that all 1L first-year law students take an AI course. We’re teaching them how to use it ethically and responsibly. Berkeley Law, for example, a top 10 law school, has now completely banned AI, so they cannot use AI at all. If you do, it’s considered academic dishonesty and misconduct, and they will face sanctions. Tribal governments are all reacting to this very differently. Whether they’re allowing it for certain things like in healthcare, maybe because they’re a rural community and they need to have it in that area, or if it’s in gaming, each tribe determines for themselves how they want to use AI. But that’s where I think we need to do the most work, because this requires updates to our policies and procedures, and we need to get moving on this rather quickly.
00:14:01 Danielle Finn Because you might have people that you employ that come from the outside, and they might not know the rules of the tribe. It might be an unspoken rule. I know for my tribe specifically, the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, we kind of have this unspoken thing of let’s not use it for certain things like entering, cultural information. Or entering children’s names or things that could be distinct, but if someone’s employed from the outside, they might not know those internal rules. So you have to have those in policies and procedures, and we need to get moving on that. I think as Tribal communities right now on how we want to use AI.
00:14:37 Jonathan Eaton I’ll flip that around. Where do you see people successfully using AI within those guardrails and boundaries?
00:14:44 Danielle Finn They do it everywhere. From healthcare to gaming to education, I think right now we’re all championing AI in such a great way. We use G Suite, so we get Gemini for free. All of our students are using it, and it is so cool. It’s great. I’ll just tell you all: For my final exam for federal Indian law, I gave them complex jurisdictional questions, and even I fed them through AI because I wanted to see whether it got them right. It didn’t, all the way. Which was great, because it couldn’t pinpoint exactly all the small Tribes or the big Tribes that I picked out and their locations.
00:15:21 Jonathan Eaton That’s okay. I’m a Jedi sometimes.
00:15:23 Danielle Finn But we teach our students, and when I’m talking to my clerks who work for me as a judge, I tell them to disclose things ethically and honestly. Be open with how you’re using AI. I think even as attorneys, we have to disclose it to our clients: ‘We used AI on this brief, and this is how we used it.’ For my students, I say, ‘Tell me what you did on this exam. Did you use Grammarly for your spelling and grammar?’ Did you use Claude to get research assistance? Did you use ChatGPT to give you direction? Tell me what you did. Just disclose it, so I know. Teaching it, teaching how to use it ethically, responsibly, honestly. Tribes can do this. We can tell our communities where we should be in our systems using AI or not using AI.
00:16:17 Jonathan Eaton Patrick, I’m not sure if you have any examples on the Tribal government side involving successful AI adoption, specific applications, or similar uses.
00:16:26 Patrick Tinklenberg One of the things I was talking about with the CIO for Cherokee Nation Health a couple of months ago, and I was shocked when we were talking about AI and the ways they’re using it there. They’re using it for transcription. Every single one of their physicians is using it for transcription. He says it’s everywhere. He says they’re using it nonstop, and it’s unbelievably helpful for their doctors. Nurses, clinicians. The folks that are part of that healthcare system, and it is a big healthcare system. And it’s saved them tons of time on transcription. I thought that was a great use case. I talked with Mo Smith. Who’s the director of our clinic out in Spokane, and they’re just starting to look at using that at the clinic. I think that’s a great example of how it can be really beneficial if it’s used in a directed way, where you know exactly how you’re going to use it, what’s going into it, and you’ve trained the people doing it.
00:17:35 Patrick Tinklenberg About who makes decisions around AI, I think one thing you have to be really aware of is that it’s not just a technology platform. It’s a system that impacts everybody. When you start talking about how you’re making decisions, you have to have a really broad group of people involved, whether it’s a steering committee or some other group. At Sycuan, we’ve got the technology people, but we’ve also got people from Tribal government. We’ve got council members. We’ve got our legal team. We’ve got HR. They’re all part of this steering committee because it has to include a broad group of people. You can’t just dump it on legal. You can’t just dump it on IT and say, ‘You guys make all the decisions.’ When you start this process, if you haven’t already, make sure you’re incorporating perspectives from every part of the organization.
00:18:40 Jonathan Eaton I’ve never seen so many nerds at business conferences and so many suits at nerd conferences lately, and I think there’s a good reason for that, right? Sorry, Danielle.
00:18:51 Danielle Finn I’m jumping off with Patrick, and I also think make it generational. He’s saying everybody. I think that’s great. We need everybody, and that’s what the law school did when we did our AI committee and how to establish what we were going to do and create this new course. We invited the students from undergrad, graduate, and the law students, but then everybody from the tenure professors who were there since the start of the law school for over forty years. We invited everybody because it’s going to impact all generations. So we make it inclusive.
00:19:22 Jonathan Eaton So, a question for you, Danielle: Where are the lines drawn?
00:19:28 Patrick Tinklenberg Typically
00:19:29 Jonathan Eaton And how are they drawn? You think in the decision-making process, especially coming down from the tribe and anything you see or studied on
00:19:38 Danielle Finn Etc. So again, a lot of the Tribes are kind of doing the internal, unspoken type of rules. I know as a sitting judge. There’s been no adoption from the Cheyenne River tribe on how we’re using AI in the government itself. So I use AI, and I feed it prompts. I’ve trained my AI to help me, especially if I’m the on-call judge and I have to take cases where the police call me in the middle of the night. I need to issue a warrant very quickly. I have a prompt all set up with a template, and I feed it that so I can get it out very quickly. Why is that important? Our communities need to be safe. If the police need a warrant really quickly, I want to be able to produce that warrant quickly. It would take me much more time to type out all of the law and everything, but if I have a template set up and can use a prompt, that helps with speed. It comes down to different areas. Tribal governments themselves can make the overall rule. Individual committees in healthcare, law, education, and other areas can make decisions as well. Every Tribe and every institution is approaching this differently.
00:20:49 Danielle Finn There’s all of you in the audience right now. You all come from different Tribes and backgrounds, and I’m sure how your tribe is approaching AI is very differently. You know it goes to the leadership and then it goes to the people, and the people themselves are the power. So you can determine how your community really wants to utilize AI and where is that boundary? What is the boundary? It’s up to you.
00:21:18 Jonathan Eaton I just shifted gears a little bit, building on what you’re talking about. There are a lot of questions about what AI means for the workforce. A lot of people are asking: Are we replacing people? Is it an augmentation? Are we all becoming cyborgs? What’s going on here? And I’m curious, Patrick. How are you communicating that when people ask those kinds of questions internally? Has there been any strategy around how that is communicated?
00:21:46 Patrick Tinklenberg That’s great. Actually, I’m glad we’re getting this. I’m really interested. I don’t know how many of you have seen some of the videos of some of the commencement speeches where people were talking about AI and getting booed. Talking about AI and people coming out of college thinking that they have no opportunity because AI is taking all the jobs. So when you’re starting these projects internally within your organization, there is going to be a ton of fear, uncertainty and doubt around these projects because we sit and talk with our casino hosts. We talk with our call center people. I talk with my own team in IT. I’ve got a help desk team that’s worried AI will take their jobs because somebody will just call IT and chat with an IT bot that helps them, and they’re not going to need the IT people. The same goes for the call center and the hosts. There are so many people who are worried about AI taking their jobs. You have to have a good message on that, and the Tribe, to its credit, and our executive team as well… Has really made a conscious decision to say, listen, AI is going to augment the people we have.
00:23:06 Patrick Tinklenberg It’s going to make their jobs easier and give them an opportunity to be more hands-on and focused with our guests. It will give them an opportunity to spend more time and function at a higher level in their job, rather than just completely replacing them. There is no part of what we are planning for AI at the Tribal government level, or in healthcare, education, where we are expecting AI to Remove them from these positions. There’s a certain amount of. Productivity gains that you get from that, and so you may not necessarily need to hire more people as you grow. So it may not be taking away jobs, but may also mean that you’re not necessarily having to hire more people. But you have to craft that message. You have to let the people know because if you want to implement something and everyone’s scared that it’s taking their job, it will not be a successful program. You will absolutely that project will fail a hundred times out of a hundred because you don’t have buy-in. People. If you haven’t given them some assurance that this is here to help them, then you will lose. And so it’s important. That’s why I said, when you build that steering committee
00:24:18 Patrick Tinklenberg Make sure that HR is on that steering committee because they’re the ones who are going to have to be talking to people about why this is good for them and why it’s not taking jobs.
00:24:27 Jonathan Eaton So getting people trained empowers them too, right? And maybe takes a little fear away. A lot of you in this room remember when Google was really a thing. When it was first started coming out, we all kind of built that muscle. I remember that first year trying to get good results out of Google. You type in food, of course you’re going to get junk results. But over time, you build that muscle. You realize, what kind of stuff do I type into Google to be able to get the result I’m looking for, and I think the same kind of muscle has to get built. To have humans be able to interface with AI better and get more out of it. The people that figure out where AI shortcomings are and strengths through that kind of interaction.
00:25:19 Jonathan Eaton The people who figure out AI’s shortcomings and strengths through that kind of interaction are the people likely to flourish over time. But it’s interesting that you mentioned not hiring people. In a way, it’s like taking away future jobs, potentially. So there’s that aspect of it. I don’t mean to put you on the spot, but you’re not the first person to mention that in these kinds of conversations. I always think that’s very interesting. What does it mean when we’re taking away jobs from the future? Because it does make sense.
00:25:49 Patrick Tinklenberg Sorry. I, I think I think it’s naive to think that productivity gains mean there’s not going to be a certain number of positions that don’t end up happening. The goal is to be more productive with the folks that we have. There will be new jobs that come out of AI, and people need to understand that the bots are real. This isn’t going away. Let’s train people to be better consumers of AI. That they’re better users of AI and better workers that incorporate this into their daily lives or into their work activities because it’s gonna keep happening. It’s gonna keep growing. It’s just not going away. And so if you can do that and you can train people and help them get better, they’re gonna have more opportunity, not less. And I think that’s the message you need to get.
00:26:53 Jonathan Eaton The growth has been phenomenal. It looks like it’s going to be parabolic still for a while. So we have to definitely keep up with it operationally. Curious, Danielle, on just those points, what are your thoughts?
00:27:09 Danielle Finn So I don’t think AI is gonna replace everybody. It can’t replace everybody. In fact, as you’re saying, it could create more jobs. We need more people to oversee AI. In law, right now we’re seeing where AI is hallucinating on citations and just going crazy on rambling on different things. As lawyers, it’s our responsibility to do our due diligence and check everything out. We’re not being replaced. It’s helping us with speed and efficiency, but we still have to do everything as a human. It’s up to us with our judgment still. Humans hold relationships. We hold judgment. AI doesn’t do that. And I think that’s the most important thing. I actually think that AI. It’s going to bring humans closer together. I was talking to my friend Ken earlier, and I think we were saying that people crave human bonds, right? As much as I talk to my AI every day, it’s not going to like me forever. I feel like once the robots come, I might die from a robot. But I truly think it’s going to drive us as humans closer together in many ways, and I feel like we should thoughtfully embrace AI.
00:28:22 Danielle Finn I’m from the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, right? Water is life. The NoDAPL movement. I was scared of AI and what it could do. But now, seeing from the legal perspective how to embrace it and really champion what it can do to help our communities, I’m really for it in certain ways. We should embrace it because there are many things in our past that our people have had to embrace. Cars, right? Lakotas were out there walking, running, and riding horses, and then cars came along. Cars were messy, and there weren’t such great things about cars. Now we’re moving into electric vehicles, where they’re not hurting the environment as much, and so on. We’re moving through progress. I see AI the same way. Not all AI is equally great, but we’re moving through that progress, and I think we’re going to get to a good point eventually.
00:29:18 Jonathan Eaton You kind of touched on something, which is that erosion of institutional knowledge that seems to be at risk to a certain extent with AI. Is that how you see it? Do you see that as a real risk? Are there any mitigations for those kinds of things?
00:29:37 Danielle Finn No. I think it could be a positive. AI could do a lot of reporting, and that institutional knowledge could become part of the training data.
00:29:46 Jonathan Eaton Patrick, that same question for you. If, for instance, you have an engineer in your IT department who knows all these things, and he or she starts using ChatGPT to create configurations for all those devices, what happens when something goes catastrophically wrong? Any thoughts on that?
00:30:07 Patrick Tinklenberg Honestly I think there’s this idea that there’s a certain amount of skill and acuity that happens right when you’re leveraging AI. And so I am notoriously an AI skeptic a little bit. I use it, but I also every time I read something from one of my team members I ask them about it to make sure they understand what they just delivered to me. Because they can use AI to create something. But if they didn’t understand what they were asking when they asked AI to build it, then they didn’t understand what the output was. And I need to make sure that they understand what they asked and what the output was, and that they validated that output. You talked a little bit about the hallucination stuff. There was a great study where they actually ran a bunch of AI platforms and they fed them scenarios, these war scenarios in. I forget what it was like. Eighty-seven out of a hundred scenarios they gave it, the AIs chose to use nuclear weapons. Right at the end of it AI doesn’t have good judgment.
00:31:27 Danielle Finn That’s right.
00:31:28 Patrick Tinklenberg It really doesn’t sometimes, and so you’ve got to have people who are validating these scenarios and validating the output. When we talk about how it’s being used, there are scenarios where automation and similar uses are perfectly acceptable, such as speeding up repetitive processes. That’s great. But if teams or people in your organization are using it, they need to understand what they’re putting in and what they’re getting out. They need to be knowledgeable enough to ask, at the end of the day, ‘Is this a reasonable output from the AI?’
00:32:03 Jonathan Eaton So Danielle, a question for you. Kind of shifting gears here. Let’s think about tomorrow. Let’s pretend we just started from scratch, and I know you have personal engagement with AI and some institutional applications. Where would you start if you could start from scratch on Monday, with everything you know now?
00:32:29 Danielle Finn Policies and the rules outlining how we should govern AI. Get the parameters for where you would like to use it and how you would like to use it. The law school has put an AI committee together. We have to offer a course. So I would do the policies first, then start with the training because everybody needs to be trained. From there, take action and use it, but continue maintaining it and keeping up. Revisit and reform it. Is it working? Is it not working? I would start with policies, then training, then embrace how it can be effective, and finally see whether it’s working for your organization or Tribe.
00:33:14 Jonathan Eaton Same question for you, Patrick.
00:33:17 Patrick Tinklenberg Policies for sure. Honestly, the one area that we realized we were really deficient on was understanding our data. I would say data governance, data classification is an important starting point. Not everyone understands where their data lives, who has access to it, what rights are assigned to it, and how important it is. Most of us have hard drives that are full of tons and tons of data. Then we dump all that data into these AI platforms and ask them to give us results. If I’m putting HR data or employee salary data into an AI platform that my entire organization can access, should everyone in the organization have access to everyone’s salary? Probably not. But we need to know that before we start dumping the data in there. We need to know what’s important to us. What is it? Is it information on our heritage, on language? Is it information about our guests at the casino? Is it financial information? What’s going in? Who should have access to it? And did we classify all of that and set up the permissions ahead of time so that when one of my IT people is running the AI platform, they can’t pull out all of the tribe’s financials?
00:34:36 Patrick Tinklenberg Because it all happens to be in the same platform, there have to be rules around that. I would say the data classification, data governance piece is really important. Policies Unbelievably important. Then you need that group of people making decisions, right? You need that steering committee or governance framework in place with people deciding what’s important, what should be done, and what shouldn’t be done.
00:35:01 Jonathan Eaton I think just to build on what you’re saying, I see especially in the complex structures around Tribes, you have Tribal government, a lot of regulatory people at the gaming commission, IT leadership, all of that, and a whole lot of data, and you kind of put all that in there. People’s expectations, their communication, all that stuff is so incredibly important, and what I have come to believe is that data classification, at least at a high level, needs to be cultural. Cultural, not just something that IT has in a document somewhere. You still have the risk of people going home and using AI on sensitive information. Their brain is a data-exfiltration device. They go home and may put sensitive information into a personal ChatGPT account, and that’s a problem. So it has to be a cultural thing. In my opinion, everyone from the Tribal chairperson to the person hired last week should broadly understand what those three or four data-classification tiers are.
00:35:36 Jonathan Eaton It you still have the risk of people going home and using AI on sensitive information. Their brain is a data exfiltration device, and they go in and they may put sensitive information into ChatGPT. That’s their personal account, and that’s a problem. So it’s got to be a cultural thing. And I believe, in my opinion, but the Tribal chairperson all the way down to the person hired last week should understand broadly what those three or four data classification tiers are. And what’s okay and what’s not with those. I think that helps a lot with communication and understanding up and down the structure.
00:36:17 Patrick Tinklenberg It’s hard because it’s so boring.
00:36:20 Jonathan Eaton It is boring. I’m glad you guys are all still awake out there.
00:36:25 Patrick Tinklenberg I don’t even want to talk about it because I thought I would put all of you to sleep. It is hard, boring, tedious, and time-consuming.
00:36:33 Jonathan Eaton But you have to do it. It’s incredibly important. All AI is built on top of this. One of AI’s main fuel sources, the input it processes, is data and how well that data is classified and organized. I know we’re coming up on time. And we want to take some questions. I saw your hand there first. We can start here.
00:37:00 Patrick Tinklenberg Why don’t you take this? All right here.
00:37:05 Jonathan Eaton Good show. Thanks, Kim. Thank you so much.
00:37:14 Audience Member #1 I have a comment and then a question. My comment is: I am so desperate for Indian Country to take its stance on AI. As somebody who submits proposals to speak at conferences, it has been instrumental in asking what the most pertinent information is for TLC. What is at the top of their list? What should I deliver? That will be much different from another conference because each audience’s focus is different. I need to know the top issues. After submitting proposals, we started hearing, ‘We can see that 70 percent of you used AI, and the other 30 percent went in the garbage.’ Then some people say, ‘Seventy percent of you used AI, and they all went in the garbage.’ And you think, ‘Oh my gosh, what do I do?’ There is no clarity. It is so helpful for us in finding the richest information, and yet you’re penalized for using it. So it’s very unclear everywhere. My question is: Have we even talked about data centers, what they’re doing to the environment, and how we need to take a closer look at that? AI is a bad word around some people because of data centers. And I think it needs a spot at the table before we rush into the tsunami of using it.
00:38:42 Audience Member #2 And then we literally look outside of our windows.
00:38:45 Audience Member #1 Data center, data center
00:38:47 Jonathan Eaton Data center. How do you feel about data centers?
00:38:55 Danielle Finn I’ll go first. Again, I’m a citizen of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe. Mni Wiconi. Water is life, and water is absolutely central to this data-center development. I think, again, going back to my car analogy… When things first start out, there’s not a lot of regulation or policy surrounding it, even at the federal level. When cars were being developed There were oil and gas leaks, and they were just not as safe. There weren’t even seatbelts, things like that. As time has developed, there’s been more regulation and more federal standards, and I think that’s where AI is headed. AI needs to have regulation by the federal government. It needs to be regulated. It needs to have these standards. The companies need to be held accountable. What is your recycling water usage? What are you doing? What is your intake? How much intake can you have or can’t you have? What are you doing to help the environment to offset what you’re doing? Things like that. And I think that’s where really all of us need to be at the table and pushing the policymakers. Policies developed by the people. People push.
00:40:09 Danielle Finn Public perception drives public policy. As the public, we need to hold them accountable. We can use ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini and love them, but we need to talk to our lawmakers and Tribal governments and say we need to start pushing these AI companies and data centers toward more sustainable infrastructure. That’s my position right now.
00:40:34 Patrick Tinklenberg I’ll be clear. I think that’s an incredibly important point. And I think people need to be intentional about it. They need to really think about when and where and how these data centers should be built. We are trying to build a microgrid at Sycuan. We can’t get generators right now because all of the generators are being used for data centers. What could have been a two-year project is now five or six years out because we can’t get access to the technology and systems we need. I think people need to understand what the impact is. You need to be going with eyes wide open. The water piece is unbelievably important. Data centers shouldn’t be built willy-nilly wherever you can put a 100,000 square foot building. We don’t want to do that. What we want to do is understand if this is appropriate for this location. If it’s not, we should absolutely not build it there.
00:41:38 Jonathan Eaton Let’s get another question in over here.
00:41:47 Audience Member Good morning, Patrick. Can you unpack and expand on what you meant when you said AI will allow your workers to work at a higher level? I hear that often, and I want to understand what people mean when they say it.
00:42:01 Patrick Tinklenberg So I think And I’ll use our host team as an example. Our casino hosts spend a lot of time doing a lot of manual tasks, whether it’s sending out invitations to events or looking up information on what player activity has happened over the past 30, 60, or 90 days. Then they have to assimilate a lot of that data and make decisions about who should get what kinds of offers and all of that stuff. They’re not necessarily out on the casino floor. Talking to people Which is really what casino hosts should be doing. And so if we can take all of those other tasks where they would be sitting at a desk in front of a computer, have those automated. And then have them out on the floor so that they’re in front of our guests. Learning about our guests certainly helps with AML and knowing our clients. It also makes our guests feel more comfortable and gives them a personal relationship with the people in our organization. Those are the kinds of things we want our team members doing.
00:43:12 Patrick Tinklenberg That’s the higher level function of their job. That’s where they add value to our organizations. That’s what we want them focusing on. We don’t want them sitting down writing emails. We don’t want them filling out spreadsheets and putting data into those. We want them in front of our guests. Same thing with the call center. The automated easy stuff. What time is the pool open? What time is the restaurant? What events are going on? Those things. We have call center agents that are taking those questions and answering them. They don’t need to be. What they need to be doing is having higher level conversations with the guests we’re calling in. That’s where we’re hoping to add that value using AI with our team members.
00:43:56 Jonathan Eaton I think we can squeeze one quick question in if anybody’s got one.
00:44:10 Danielle Finn Hello.
00:44:12 Audience Member #2 So I have a couple of things. In response to your question, I’m our Tribal administrator, and there’s an Indigenous-built AI called Syncurrent that helps Tribes look for grants, deadlines, and information. Specific to Tribes, that’s how it’s helping me in my job. I read an article about work with the Māori in New Zealand, where they’re creating a cultural data seed bank. One of the people who built it had a quote that I really liked. Data is the last frontier of colonization. And so my question is: Do you think it would be more prudent for Tribal Nations to build out their own AI platforms rather than feed this kind of data, including proprietary data, into these existing models?
00:45:28 Jonathan Eaton I think there are two ways to look at the data-sovereignty piece you’re touching on. It’s up to the Tribe. What you’re saying certainly resonates with a lot of people I see. One option is to take it all in-house completely, and there are ways to do that. Those systems are never going to be as smart or as capable as the frontier models. When I say frontier models, I mean ChatGPT, Gemini, and those kinds of systems. They’re always going to be ahead of the game with their intelligence. But there are ways to run things locally, and of course that’s perfect data sovereignty. There’s middle ground too, and the middle ground is that you have a contract. Of course, that’s up to the Tribal values and where you trust these companies, but there are legal instruments to be able to have that data sovereignty extend to the organization you’re doing business with. I think we’re out of time. Much appreciated, everybody. Thank you so much.
